OK.
So... uhm. I guess his move-set had one of Chris Masters or Bret Harts moves or something in it.
Because it won't let you upload any content from downloadable superstars in the game. Even a move in a move set, like a DDT or something.
I wiped his moveset clean, and completly replace it with Shelton Benjiman's moveset, and his finishers. You might wanna go mess with that.